If you’ve been glued to your screen watching Jonasi Gomora’s chaotic downfall in Netflix’s The Polygamist, you’re not alone. The show has taken Mzansi by storm, even climbing global charts and sparking water-cooler debates from Johannesburg to the UK. But as we binge, a crucial question is nagging at many of us who know the reality of isithembu: is this actually polygamy, or just a story of a man with a pathological need for deceit?
While the series, adapted from Sue Nyathi’s novel, gives us a world of secrets, manipulation, and tragic endings, it feels a world away from the practice many of us grew up understanding. The chorus of voices pointing this out is growing, with cultural commentators like author Bhekisisa Mncube arguing the show confuses “sexual deviance” with culture. But beyond the outrage, there’s a critical lesson being overlooked in the hype—one about the true, often misunderstood, spirit of polygamy.
The headline-grabbing take from reality TV star Busisiwe “MaCele” Mseleku, first wife of Musa Mseleku, hints at this disconnect. She controversially suggested that Jonasi’s downfall was caused by his wives not keeping the home peaceful, arguing that men like peace and will stray when confronted with conflict. While many lashed out at her for seemingly “missing the point,” her comments inadvertently highlight a far deeper truth: in a real polygamous setup, the man’s wandering is not tolerated—because it’s not supposed to happen in the first place.
As one writer put it, “That is not polygamy. That is sexual misconduct”. The core of traditional polygamy is not about a man’s unchecked libido. It’s a complex social contract governed by family, duty, and, most importantly, the agency of the senior wife. In the authentic practice of isithembu, it is often the wife or wives who decide to bring in a new partner. A married man doesn’t go out looking for a new wife; his wife invites help—perhaps to bear children if she is barren, or to fulfil a family obligation, such as ukungena (entering the house of a deceased brother to care for his children). The goal is continuity, family expansion, and collective responsibility, not secrecy. The institution was built on the principle that elder wives hold significant power, and the husband’s duty is to the family unit, not to fulfil his own lustful desires.
This is where the series does a disservice. It presents a man whose compulsive behaviour leads to his demise from an STI, ignoring that the genuine cultural framework includes rules and safeguards. When done properly, the spirit of polygamy ensures a man should never be “cheating” on his wives in secret or courting other women behind their backs because the entire arrangement is built on transparency and the consent of the family. Jonasi Gomora is a cautionary tale of a man abusing power, not a reflection of a cultural practice.
And yes, culture is not static—it is made by the elders and can always shift. But the show’s failure to interrogate the distinction between cultural practice and personal pathology is a poison. The real lesson for South African audiences is to recognise the difference between a man who lies and a man who lives by the rules of a complex tradition. As the debates rage on social media, let’s ensure we aren’t letting a Netflix drama rewrite the history of a practice that, at its core, was about family and community, not deception.



